
Danny Wolohan, Esco Jouléy, Mary Wiseman, Will Pullen, and Celia Keenan-Bolger in The Visitors. Photo: Joan Marcus
How much do you really love your siblings, and what would you do for them? Let’s say one of them has a new baby and there’s something dodgy in their marriage. Or they’re about to relapse into addiction for the umpteenth time. Or they have a potentially fatal disease. You might live three thousand miles away. You might have been out of contact for the better part of a decade. You might have some pretty heavy stuff on your own plate. When your baby sister calls, do you drop everything and go? When she asks you for an impossible favor, will you do it? Will you also ask what’s in it for you?
As Tolstoy famously said, “All happy families are alike; each unhappy family is unhappy in its own way.” In Bryna Turner’s The Visitors, we don’t learn a ton about the Delaney family as a unit, but most of the memories they rehash involve conflict or trauma, and one of them says they weren’t “smothered in love every single day of [their] lives.” The way in which they’re unhappy is cutting off the black sheep, retreating to their own self-absorption, and showing up for weddings, funerals, and crises. But now Joanna (Mary Wiseman), the baby sister, has summoned all three of her siblings to her New York apartment ASAP.
Joanna is in her late thirties, of unspecified profession but a pretty hip life. She and her spouse, Naomi (Esco Jouléy), live in a spacious loft with big windows and comfortable furniture and a collection of vintage vinyl. (I don’t entirely believe they could afford the apartment depicted in Kate Noll’s set, but it’s a wonderland of telling detail, from the tools of Naomi’s trade as a props designer stowed under the dining room table while they have guests to the framed Playbills and photos on the wall to the bright handmade throw pillows on the couch.) In the wake of the death of Naomi’s mother (she who did smother her only child with love), Jo and Naomi have started thinking about having a baby of their own—only to find out when Jo gets fertility testing that she’s in kidney failure. At a hastily convened family summit, she’s going to ask her siblings to save her life.
But their mom cut off eldest son Rory (Danny Wolohan) after his last failed drug intervention, and the four of them haven’t been in the same room in a very long time. Tess (Celia Keenan-Bolger), ten years older than Jo, feels like she had to be a parent to her siblings, and then went straight on to raise her own daughter. She’s desperate to figure out who she is, as an adult. Henry (Will Pullen), the younger son, is a ruthless pragmatist with anger management issues, toting a newborn he has no idea how to parent. And then there’s Rory, with his drug problem, his criminal record, and his kid in foster care. The family exiled him long since, but now Jo’s tracked him down. (It wasn’t that hard, which shows how little any of them cared to do it.) Because she needs a kidney, and her siblings are the best chance of finding a compatible donor.
The stakes are literally life and death, but the siblings remain trapped in old arguments, repeating old patterns, slowly peeling away layers of concern to reveal the naked self-interest beneath. And as the play goes on, the gloves—and the wheels—truly come off, much to the discomfort of would-be peacemaker Naomi, who’s never experienced this kind of intrafamily conflict nor spent so much time cooped up in a space with their in-laws. (The script doesn’t specify racial identities for the characters, but director Jenna Worsham has cast in a way that underscores some of the alliances and fissures. Naomi is a non-binary vegan and aspiring Buddhist, and also the only Black person in a room with four white siblings. Joanna, Tess, and Henry are slight of frame, quick-moving, quick-talking and fair in coloring; Wolohan’s Rory is larger, slower, solider, always a beat behind.)
The material could skew to Eugene O’Neill levels of dysfunction and tragedy (though with much less alcohol; Tess is perkily desperate for a glass of wine throughout, but between Joanna’s illness, Rory’s addiction issues, Henry’s scornful devotion to clean eating, and Naomi’s ascetic veganism, no one else cares). But the tone remains tart—sometimes to a fault, so that the turn to realer emotions at the end is a sharp pivot.
Turner is as interested in the comedy of putting these four combustible personalities–and poor Naomi’s best efforts at turning down the temperature–as they are in the emotional undercurrents of generosity and obligation that swirl around as each sibling gets tested and reveals their results. (Jouléy’s Naomi strikes the right balance of insufferable magnanimity and genuine care for their partner; when they lose their patience, you know Jo has really gone too far.) These characters aren’t used to emotional disclosures—just stewing internally over their resentments or flaring into outbursts of petulance, pettiness, or rage: Either Rory’s addiction and criminality or Henry’s anger management issues usually take center stage. Both Joanna and Tess, more socialized to go along and get along, are desperate to, just once, have something be about them. And in both Keenan-Bolger’s and Pullen’s performances, you see the strain of burdens they can’t quite handle come out as “admiration” of Jo’s “lack of responsibilities”–the life she’s made for herself with Naomi can’t possibly be as important as their own. In Worsham’s hands, you see the double consciousness in all of them—they love each other, sure. But there’s not an ounce of trust to go around, and each sibling is running their own battle campaign. They’re all selfish, and they all think they have equal right to be.
As one sibling after another regretfully confesses their ineligibility to donate on the grounds of high blood pressure, Jo learns one of them is in fact eligible—but not which. And as the tension mounts, so does the inability to keep their manners about them. You may think you know how far these supposedly civilized people will go to protect their secrets. You’d be wrong.
Jo’s determination to figure out which of her siblings is lying to her takes the whole thing over the top, tapping into a rage that Jo’s been suppressing her whole life—and opening the door for all of the siblings to reveal the dark undersides of their supposed support. It’s a big mode shift for all the siblings, and in hindsight, Pullen and Keenan-Bolger are more successful at laying the groundwork for the pivot than Wolohan and Wiseman.
In the end, it’s Jo and Naomi’s relationship that proves capable of the honesty that might get them through; Jouléy and Wiseman arrive at a weary tenderness that’s evolved past the pair who were introduced hyperbolically cooling over their niece. Still, Naomi is newly wary. “There’s a long way to travel,” they say, “from ‘I don’t know what to do’ to ‘pulling a knife on my relatives.” Maybe for someone from a happy family, that’s true.