Reviews • NYC • Off-Broadway Published 16 November 2026

Review: The Unbelievers at MTC

New York City Center - Stage I ⋄ 13th October - 29th November 2026

Nick Payne’s new play undermines its own tension and drama. Nicole Serratore reviews.

Nicole Serratore

Tom Riley and Lauren Ambrose in The Unbelievers (Photo: Matthew Murphy)

The agony of not-knowing what has happened to a missing family member is a pain the whole family feels. But Nick Payne’s play The Unbelievers centers a British mother’s grief, anger, fury, and love when her teenage son Oscar goes missing without a word. But with too tight a focus on the mother’s experience in her circuitous grief, the play keeps defusing its own tension and running in circles. It’s an elegantly designed and directed production, but it has nowhere to go.

The mother, Miriam (Lauren Ambrose), isn’t all that maternal. She confesses this, though no one needs to be told, because throughout the play she demonstrates that she has no ability to comfort or care for those around her. Maybe the limited timeframe is the issue. We do not see Miriam at all before Oscar’s disappearance. Was she an A+ mum then? Everything we see is in the aftermath, and that is the only Miriam we meet—an acerbic, narcissistic, cruel, thoughtless, violent, and angry person. She is trapped in her misery, and we are locked in with her.

Payne is arguably trying to set up Miriam in the fight of her life for her son against all the unbelievers around her. But it is a one-note battle to watch. The play’s questions of faith are not really about organized religion. However, the set by Paul Steinberg uses on-stage seating in wooden pews and an arched church window through which the theater audience can peer and view the on-stage audience. And the extended family fights over a church service for Oscar, with Miriam (an atheist) furiously demanding to know whether there will be prayers and hymns.

But the faith that Miriam is really struggling with involves the people around her. She is keeping a forever vigil in her head for Oscar. In her mind, he is not dead, and she must always be looking for him, doing everything in her power to bring him home. The others are wrestling with whether he ran away or if he was taken and harmed, and their feelings vacillate depending on what might have happened. But Miriam she cannot countenance any other way forward but her own, alienating everyone else around her.

Payne plays with time leaps, as he has in past plays, and we move from a year after Oscar went missing, to days after, to seven years after, to dates unknown. Director Knud Adams stages this seamlessly, with maybe a slight change in lighting as characters enter and exit through a vast abyss of a black doorway; as Miriam is still reeling over one moment, another strikes her. So she ping-pongs through this family tragedy in a relentless series of conflicts and confrontations.

And Miriam herself is in crisis. Her family is in tatters, not only because the son is gone but because she is at risk of doing harm to herself or others. There is genuine fear among the family still there. But in the same breath, Miriam is always digging the knife into her children and ex-husbands with a withering look, a sharp retort, or an indifference to their feelings.

Fish by Melis Aker also deals with the aftermath of a son gone missing from the UK and the forgotten sister left behind. In both plays, the mothers are obsessed with investigating what has happened to their sons. But Aker centers the teenage daughter while giving us a window into the mother’s pain and struggles. It is a more nuanced approach in many ways.

Payne has taken such a scorched-earth approach to mothering that I’m not sure how much pain we are supposed to endure when Miriam tortures her two still-present children, failing them time and time again. Are we meant to excuse her because she is suffering too?

The Unbelievers (Photo: Matthew Murphy)

Payne sometimes tries to open up the narrative frame a bit to see how Oscar’s father, David (Tom Riley), is handling things, as well as his half-sibling Nancy (Nina Ross) and his sister Mags (Elizabeth Yeoman). But all of these moments still involve Miriam as well as a participant, an agitator, an antagonist, or an observer. Every time another character attempts a nuanced, emotional conversation about Oscar’s disappearance or how they feel, Miriam shuts it down. It frankly snuffs out the drama.

Ambrose is not a caricature, but Payne has built her a limited space to work in. It is all frenzy, fury, and rage which she achieves. She is a hummingbird slicing the air with her hands, always moving. When she stops, it is as if we are watching the pot boil, knowing she will explode.

For the most part, it feels like the rest of the cast has little to do except argue and weep. There are several original songs by Will Butler that are part of the play. Nancy is a music student. So Ross beautifully plays and sings the songs, which provide the few moments in the play that move the focus away from Miriam. But everyone’s work largely feels thankless in a play that does not want to cede space to these other voices.

Maybe, like her family, we too are waiting for Miriam to move onto another phase of grief, and she refuses to go, and she resents that you would even ask that of her. While we might sympathize with the family’s frustrations with Miriam, in the waiting, we end up with a laundry list of our own.

Nicole Serratore

Nicole Serratore writes about theater for Variety, The Stage, American Theatre magazine, and TDF Stages. She previously wrote for the Village Voice and Flavorpill. She was a co-host and co-producer of the Maxamoo theater podcast. She is a member of the Drama Desk and Outer Critics Circle.

Review: The Unbelievers at MTC Show Info


Produced by Manhattan Theatre Club

Directed by Knud Adams

Written by Nick Payne

Scenic Design Paul Steinberg

Costume Design Enver Chakartash

Lighting Design Masha Tsimring

Sound Design Sinan Refik Zafar

Cast includes Lauren Ambrose, Jaspal Binning, Brittany Bradford, Jack DiFalco, Marjan Neshat, Tom Riley, Nina Ross, Hadi Tabbal, and Elizabeth Yeoman


the
Exeunt
newsletter


Enter your email address below to get an occasional email with Exeunt updates and featured articles.